Home/Today's Scores

Today's Question Period

Wednesday, March 25, 2026

SESSION OVERVIEW

WEDNESDAY, MARCH 25, 2026
Pierre Poilievre

Pierre Poilievre

Leader of Opposition

B

(86%)

Question Rigor

SPIN DETECTED
6 OF 6
questions deflected
DEFLECTION RATE
100%
LOW
SPIN
HIGH
SPIN
EXTREME SPIN
Mark Carney

Mark Carney

Prime Minister

D-

(60%)

Answer Directness

6
EXCHANGES
0
DIRECT ANSWERS
6
SPIN DETECTED

Question Period session with 6 exchanges between Hon. Pierre Poilievre (Leader of the Opposition, CPC) and Right Hon. Mark Carney (Prime Minister, Lib.). Average Question Rigor: 86. Average PM Spin: 60.

Questions & Answers

#1Exchange 1 of 6
Q: B|A: D-
ConservativeQuestion02:15 p.m.

Pierre Poilievre

Leader of the Opposition

Mr. Speaker, yesterday, the Auditor General condemned the current Liberal Minister of Justice, the current Liberal Minister of Canadian Identity and Culture and the current Liberal Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship for causing chaos on the international student file. The fact is that they allowed 150,000 suspected cases of fraud to go uninvestigated. The Prime Minister gave them promotions so that they could continue to wreak havoc in the system. Will he fire them or will he continue with the same Liberal incompetence?
Question Grade

Clarity & specificity

B

85%

Question Assessment

B — The question is clear and specific, citing evidence from the Auditor General and directly asking for a commitment regarding the ministers' positions.

LiberalAnswer

Mark Carney

Prime Minister

Mr. Speaker, I am blessed with a strong cabinet that is working hard for a strong Canada. Canada's new government is regaining control of the immigration system. Asylum claims are down by a third. The number of international students has fallen by 70%. We have a strong Canada and a balanced immigration system.

Answer Grade

How directly answered

D-

62%

Sharp question met with total deflection.

Answer Assessment

D- — The answer does not address the specific question about firing ministers and instead provides unrelated talking points.

#2Exchange 2 of 6
Q: B|A: D-
ConservativeQuestion02:20 p.m.

Pierre Poilievre

Leader of the Opposition

Mr. Speaker, the new Liberals are the same as the old Liberals. The numbers the Prime Minister just gave can be compared to the even more miserable numbers of his justice minister. In fact, compared to the Harper government, which had the last sane policy on immigration, asylum claims are now up 2880%, temporary foreign workers are up 178% and international students are up 39%. Yesterday, the Auditor General condemned the current Liberal justice minister, the Liberal heritage minister and Liberal immigration minister for allowing 150,000 cases of fraud to go uninvestigated. Will the Prime Minister fire them, or will he just continue with the same Liberal incompetence?
Question Grade

Clarity & specificity

B

85%

Question Assessment

B — The question is clear and specific, citing statistics and asking a direct question about the Prime Minister's actions.

LiberalAnswer

Mark Carney

Prime Minister

Mr. Speaker, I am blessed with a strong cabinet that is working hard for a strong country. We are taking control of the immigration system. Asylum seekers are down by a third, foreign students are down by 60% and temporary foreign workers are down by 50%. The population equilibrated, is equal. We are investigating 100% of the fraud cases since the new government came to office. We have the system under control.

Answer Grade

How directly answered

D-

62%

Sharp question met with vague reassurances.

Answer Assessment

D- — The answer does not address the specific accusations or statistics mentioned in the question.

#3Exchange 3 of 6
Q: B|A: D-
ConservativeQuestion02:20 p.m.

Pierre Poilievre

Leader of the Opposition

Mr. Speaker, it is all illusion. It is the same old Liberals, the same old failures. Look at the economy. The Prime Minister likes to blame world affairs for his failing economy. The G7 countries have the same world economy, yet he has delivered the second-highest unemployment in the G7, the worst household debt in the G7, the worst housing costs in the G7 and the only shrinking economy in the G7. We have had 100,000 lost jobs in the last two months alone. Why is it that, after the Prime Minister promised that he would be the first, he is the worst in the G7?
Question Grade

Clarity & specificity

B

85%

Question Assessment

B — The question is clear and specific, citing multiple economic issues and asking a direct question about the Prime Minister's performance.

LiberalAnswer

Mark Carney

Prime Minister

Mr. Speaker, let us take a look at what has happened since this summer. The United States has lost 6,000—

Answer Grade

How directly answered

D-

60%

Sharp question met with total deflection.

Answer Assessment

D- — The answer does not address the question about G7 performance and pivots to unrelated information.

#4Exchange 4 of 6
Q: B|A: D-
ConservativeQuestion02:20 p.m.

Pierre Poilievre

Leader of the Opposition

Mr. Speaker, I guess those people who stash their cash in tax havens have never had it so good and so affordable. Tell that to the single mother who is walking down the grocery aisle. Let us talk about jobs. The Prime Minister compares us to the United States. When we do an apples-to-apples comparison of unemployment, it is 1.3% higher in Canada than it is in the U.S. In fact, Canada has the second-highest unemployment in the G7, the worst grocery inflation in the G7, the most unaffordable housing in the G7 and the worst household debt in the G7. He promised we would be first, so why is he the worst?
Question Grade

Clarity & specificity

B

85%

Question Assessment

B — Clear question with specific comparisons and asks.

LiberalAnswer

Mark Carney

Prime Minister

Mr. Speaker, we have the lowest debt burden in the G7. We have the lowest deficit in the G7. We have the highest credit rating in the G7. What is this government doing? It is putting it into action with a defence industrial strategy that will bring half a trillion dollars of investment. With an auto strategy, with an electricity strategy, with a climate competitiveness strategy and with a housing strategy, we are moving forward. We are investing in this country, the second-best country in the world for foreign direct investment. We are moving forward. Come join us.

Answer Grade

How directly answered

D-

62%

Sharp question met with generic talking points.

Answer Assessment

D- — Generic response, fails to address specific issues.

#5Exchange 5 of 6
Q: B+|A: D
ConservativeQuestion02:25 p.m.

Pierre Poilievre

Leader of the Opposition

Mr. Speaker, strategies and imaginary promises will not pay the bills or fill the tank. We all know that global oil prices have gone up, but that does not explain why in Canadian dollars and in litres, Americans pay $1.46 a litre at the pump while Canadians are paying $1.70. That is 26¢ higher per litre at the pump because of the Prime Minister's anti-energy policies and his newly renamed carbon tax, the clean fuel standard. Will he get rid of these policies and get rid of that tax so Canadians can have some relief at the pumps?
Question Grade

Clarity & specificity

B+

88%

Question Assessment

B+ — The question is clear and specific, citing evidence about fuel prices and directly asking for a policy change.

LiberalAnswer

Mark Carney

Prime Minister

Mr. Speaker, I know the member opposite was not here in the spring. It is a source of great sadness. We got rid of the consumer carbon tax. That took off 18¢ per litre. What matters is the rate of growth of wages relative to overall inflation. Wages are growing at twice the rate. This country is moving forward.

Answer Grade

How directly answered

D

65%

Sharp question met with evasive response.

Answer Assessment

D — The answer acknowledges a related point but avoids addressing the core question about the carbon tax and fuel prices.

#6Exchange 6 of 6
Q: B|A: F
ConservativeQuestion02:25 p.m.

Pierre Poilievre

Leader of the Opposition

It is all an illusion, Mr. Speaker. The Prime Minister not only supported the carbon tax that he advised Justin Trudeau to put in, but thought it should be higher and broader. When he got into power, he did not get rid of it; he renamed it. He called it the Clean Fuel Standard, 7¢ a litre this year rising to 17¢ on top of an industrial carbon tax that is driving up the costs of all the industrial production of our energy. That is one of the reasons that, under the Liberal Prime Minister, Canadians pay the equivalent of 26¢ a litre more than the Americans pay. Will he stop ripping off Canadians at the pump and get rid of these Liberal taxes so Canadians can get moving?
Question Grade

Clarity & specificity

B

85%

Question Assessment

B — Good question with specific evidence and a clear ask.

LiberalAnswer

Mark Carney

Prime Minister

Mr. Speaker, we are getting this country moving with the biggest transformation of this economy in generations. We are building unprecedented amounts of affordable housing. We are building clean energy. We are lowering energy costs for Canadians. We are building a defence industrial strategy that this country has not seen since the Second World War. We are protecting Canadians. We are building this economy. We are empowering Canadians across the country.

Answer Grade

How directly answered

F

50%

Sharp question met with total deflection.

Answer Assessment

F — Complete deflection, no engagement with the question.

Like grading politicians? Get the Top 5 every Friday.

The week's worst dodges, delivered free to your inbox.